Ninetales #12, Black Flame, Base Set
- Card number: #12/102
- ·Rarity: Rare
- ·Finish: Holo
A PSA 9 Ninetales #12 Black Flame from Base Set has a TCGBerg fair value of $560 as of Nov 14, 2026. TCGBerg has recorded 9 PSA 9 sales of this card, the latest on Sep 16, 2026. PSA has graded 27 copies at PSA 9.
TCGBerg Algorithm (estimated from recorded sales).
- Population · PSA 9
- 27
- Market cap
- $15.1K
- Volatility
- 0.3%
- YTD
- ↑ 91.1%
- Sales evidence
- Moderate
TCGBerg fair value · PSA 9
$560
Price history
Weekly fair value over time, plus a confidence band around it: how precisely we can pin the value, which tightens as more sales confirm it. Dots mark individual sales, snapped to their week: red when above fair value (a premium), green when below (a deal), hollow when flagged as an outlier. Switch the active grade with the selector above.Weekly fair value for PSA 9. Shaded area is the confidence band: how precisely we can pin the value; it tightens as more sales confirm it. Dots are individual sales. Confidence band: how precisely we can pin the fair value. It widens when sales scatter and narrows as more sales back the value up. The dots show the actual sale prices.
What the evidence says
The last PSA 9 sale, $550 on Sep 16, 2026, is in line with the $560 fair value (1.8% below). The value weighs 9 PSA 9 sales from the past year, not the latest one alone. Its confidence band runs from $525 to $595. A PSA 10 ($5,188) is worth 9.3 times a PSA 9 ($560). Over the past 30 days the PSA 9 value has risen 0.4%.
TCGBerg fair value by grade
Side-by-side comparison of value across every grade and ungraded condition we track for this printing. The bar chart uses a log scale so raw and gem-mint fit on one axis. Solid bars are the TCGBerg fair value, modelled from recorded sales. Hatched bars are the latest market price instead, shown for ungraded conditions that trade too rarely for us to price one honestly.Value at each grade and ungraded condition. Log scale. Tap a row to switch the whole page.
Behind the scenes
How the published fair value for this grade was produced: the sales it rests on, how they were put together, and every recorded change afterwards. It describes one saved calculation, not a live recomputation.What goes into this price, and how much we know.
Recent sales
20 trackedEach sale against the grade's fair value on the day it sold.
| Date | Grade | Venue | Price | vs fair value |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 21, 2026 | PSA7 | eBay | $200 | above fair value by +0.2% |
| Oct 13, 2026 | PSA6 | eBay | $225 | above fair value by +55.7% |
| Oct 6, 2026 | PSA6 | eBay | $140 | above fair value by +15.4% |
| Sep 16, 2026 | PSA9 | eBay | $550 | above fair value by +4.4% |
| Sep 14, 2026 | PSA9 | eBay | $525 | below fair value by -0.4% |
- $200Oct 21, 2026 · via eBayPSA7↑above fair value by 0.2%
- $225Oct 13, 2026 · via eBayPSA6↑above fair value by 55.7%
- $140Oct 6, 2026 · via eBayPSA6↑above fair value by 15.4%
- $550Sep 16, 2026 · via eBayPSA9↑above fair value by 4.4%
- $525Sep 14, 2026 · via eBayPSA9↓below fair value by 0.4%
| Sep 2, 2026 | PSA5 | eBay | $80 | below fair value by -7.2% |
| Aug 4, 2026 | PSA9 | eBay | $395 | below fair value by -10.6% |
| Jul 30, 2026 | PSA1 | Fanatics Collect | $55 | below fair value by -13.9% |
- $80PSA5↓below fair value by 7.2%
- $395PSA9↓below fair value by 10.6%
- $55PSA1↓below fair value by 13.9%
15 more sales with Pro
Up to 20 recent sales, each with its venue and its gap to fair value.
↓Includes a sale 17.7% below fair value
All grades matrix
Every grade we track for this printing. Click any column header to sort; the rightmost column jumps you to listings for that grade.
- PSA10$5,1881d ·0.0%7d ·0.0%30d ↓5.6%
- Pop
- 4
- Mcap
- $20.8K
- Evidence
- Sparse
- Last
- $2,511
- PSA9$5601d ↓0.1%7d ↓0.3%30d ↑0.4%
- Pop
- 27
- Mcap
- $15.1K
- Evidence
- Moderate
- Last
- $550
- PSA8$2711d ·0.0%7d ↓0.2%30d ↓14.0%
- Pop
- 46
- Mcap
- $12.5K
- Evidence
- Sparse
- Last
- $337
| PSA10 | $5,188 | 4 | $20.8K | 0.0% | 0.0% | ↓down 5.6% | ↑up 32.1% | Sparse | $2,5111y ago |
| PSA9 | $560 | 27 | $15.1K | ↓down 0.1% | ↓down 0.3% | ↑up 0.4% | ↑up 26.7% | Moderate | $5502mo ago |
| PSA8 | $271 | 46 | $12.5K | 0.0% | ↓down 0.2% | ↓down 14.0% | ↑up 6.7% | Sparse | $3375mo ago |
| PSA7 | $203 | 50 | $10.1K | 0.0% | ↑up 0.8% | ↑up 22.7% | ↑up 28.8% | Strong | $2003w ago |
| PSA6 | $169 | 40 | $6.8K | 0.0% | ↓down 0.1% | ↑up 38.9% | ↑up 30.6% | Limited | $2251mo ago |
| PSA5 | $112 | 23 | - | 0.0% | 0.0% | ↑up 20.6% | ↑up 38.0% | Limited | $802mo ago |
| PSA4 | $111 | 12 | - | 0.0% | 0.0% | ↑up 20.6% | ↑up 38.0% | Sparse | $702y ago |
| PSA3 | $87 | 6 | - | ↑up 0.2% | ↑up 1.9% | ↑up 10.8% | ↑up 9.8% | Sparse | $551y ago |
| PSA2 | $86 | 5 | - | ↑up 0.2% | ↑up 1.9% | ↑up 10.8% | ↑up 9.8% | Sparse | $8010mo ago |
| PSA1 | $67 | 8 | - | ↑up 1.5% | ↓down 0.2% | ↑up 12.0% | ↑up 3.5% | Sparse | $554mo ago |
PSA population report
How Ninetales's graded copies are spread across grades. Each bar is the number of copies graded at that grade; the percentage is that grade's share of the total graded population. These are recorded graded copies, not the total print run. A smaller population alone does not establish a price premium.221 graded copies of Ninetales Black Flame across 10 grades. The selected grade is highlighted.
PSA 9 makes up 12% of graded copies: 27 of 221. PSA 7 is the most common grade (23%).
Analysis
Ninetales-Holo Black Flame - Black Flame at PSA 10 carries a TCGBerg fair value of $5,188 as of 2026-11-13. We track a TCGBerg fair value across 10 grades from Base Set, from PSA 1 up to PSA 10. A graded population of 4 copies sits behind the PSA 10 grade. The PSA 10 valuation rests on sparse sales evidence. Over the past 30 days, the PSA 10 TCGBerg fair value has fallen 5.6%.